Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Mushrooms by the truckload

Mushrooms by the truckload

  • 0

There is a long list of things the rains brought this year. High on it is a smorgasbord of edible — and non-edible — mushrooms, and area hunters have had their fill for months.

As the rains stop and the first frost approaches, that season is coming to an end. But there is still some bounty left for those willing to look.

“This was an excellent year for mushrooms,” said Catherine Gehring, an NAU professor and mushroom expert. “Mushrooms were very abundant, there were many different species and they could be found in a range of habitats. Some species of mushroom, like the Aspen Boletes, fruited early in the season and then again recently.”

The best places to hunt edible mushrooms depend on what you’re looking to eat. There are a range of edible mushrooms throughout the area that ecologists refer to as the mixed conifer vegetation zone. That range includes pines, Douglas fir, spruce and aspen.

Ponderosa forests have a number of common edibles like the iconic lobster mushroom and another local favorite, the Caesar’s Amanita. Other common favorites are barrow boletes and oyster mushrooms.

If you have a trustworthy book to use as a source, it’s reasonably easy to pick out the mushroom you’re looking for.

But mushroom identification is not something you want to get wrong, as Arizona Highways magazine learned this week when it mistakenly identified a psychotropic mushroom as edible and had to pull copies off store shelves.

“Make sure you’re identifying the mushrooms that you’re eating,” said local mushroom forager Noah Stalvey. “Never, ever eat a mushroom you’re not certain about.”

The perceived repercussions of getting it wrong keep many would-be foragers from eating forest foods.

“We haven’t ever hunted (mushrooms) before, but have always wanted to,” said Flagstaff resident Rae Bachrach. “We walk in the woods with our dogs every day, and each fall we see hundreds of mushrooms out there. … We know there is a perfectly good dinner there waiting for us, but the threat of liver damage has always stopped us.”

Noah Stalvey and his wife Debi started hunting mushrooms just a couple years ago and have already had scores many veteran hunters would envy. Last summer, they found 17 pounds worth of giant puffball mushrooms, including one massive mushroom bigger than a sack of potatoes.

He says that he’s a hunter, but his wife is a vegetarian. Foraging for mushrooms is just about the only way they can both hunt for food together.

This summer they pulled in 10 pounds worth of lobster mushrooms in one haul. Those same mushrooms sell for about $10 a pound at the Flagstaff Community Market. But some sellers at farmer’s market ensure their harvest is bug free by only pulling from the highest reaches of the San Francisco Peaks.

Some of the more common ways to prepare wild mushrooms are in soups and stir-frys, or simply sautéed. The Stalveys like to dry what they won’t eat right away in a dehydrator and use them in dishes throughout the year.

Lobster mushrooms are still prevalent in Flagstaff forests, but can often be infested with insects and worms.

“The lobsters were everywhere this year,” said Flagstaff resident and mushroom hunter Kyle Hartley.

The U.S. Forest Service does not require any special permit to collect mushrooms.

The Stalveys say they also stick to the Peaks for mushroom finding. But they’ll never reveal their best spots. In the mushroom hunting world, people won’t hesitate to tell a newcomer they’re on their foraging turf.

“If I told you, I’d have to kill you,” Noah Stalvey joked. “We all have our secret little spots and we don’t divulge them. Mushrooms are not hard to find, you just have to get off the beaten trail.”

“All That the Rain Promises and More” by David Arora is a popular book for mushroom identification and can be bought online or ordered in local shops. Another resource is a website by NAU graduate student and avid mushroom hunter Erik Nelson, Arizona Mushroom Primer. It’s at

Eric Betz can be reached at 556-2250 or


Get local news delivered to your inbox!

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News

Breaking News (FlagLive!)