SB1070 'Papers, please' now in effect

2012-09-18T13:41:00Z 2012-09-18T14:24:30Z SB1070 'Papers, please' now in effectBy HOWARD FISCHER Capitol Media Services Arizona Daily Sun
September 18, 2012 1:41 pm  • 

PHOENIX -- The "Papers, please'' provision of Arizona's SB 1070 is now in effect.

U.S. District Court Judge Susan Bolton signed the formal order this afternoon dissolving the injunction she issued more than two years ago blocking the state from enforcing key provisions of the 2010 law.

Since that time, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that she was legally incorrect in enjoining the section which requires police to question those they have stopped if there is reason to believe they are in this country illegally. The justices said there was no evidence that the Arizona law, on its face, conflicted with federal law.

Bolton's order, though, makes permanent the injunction she issued at the same time in 2010 barring enforcement of three other sections of the law. The high court agreed with her conclusions that those provisions were preempted by federal law.

The judge's order today comes as civil rights groups are asking the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for a new injunction.

They argue that the U.S. Supreme Court ruling dealt only with the issues of federal preemption. Their lawsuit is based on arguments that the law will necessarily result in racial profiling.

Bolton herself refused to issue a new injunction two weeks ago. And so far the 9th Circuit has yet to act on the request.

Attorney Linton Joaquin of the National Immigration Law Center said his organization and its allies believe there will be real harms to some people now that the law can be enforced.

"It's going to cause racial profiling,'' he said. "It's going to cause people to be stopped because of their appearance.''

Joaquin acknowledged that existing Arizona law already permits individual officers to question those they have stopped about their immigration status. But he said it is the mandate in this law that police must inquire which will make all the difference.

"What police can already do is that when they have someone lawfully in their custody, they can ask some questions,'' he said. Similarly, they can choose not to raise the issue and let people go on their way after dealing with the reason for the original stop.

Removing that discretion, Joaquin said, will create new problems as officers seek to verify legal presence in this country.

"It's not an instantaneous determination whether somebody has immigration status,'' he said. "It is, in practice, going to lead to people being detained solely for the purpose of an immigration check.''

Joaquin said one thing that Bolton's order will do is provide live examples of how the law is being enforced -- and, from his perspective, in an illegal way.

"We will definitely be encouraging people to call about cases of abuses,'' he said.

Those examples could prove crucial: In refusing to grant a new injunction, Bolton said she was bound by the conclusion of the Supreme Court that it was inappropriate to block the law even before it took effect.

Copyright 2015 Arizona Daily Sun. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

(3) Comments

  1. casca
    Report Abuse
    casca - September 19, 2012 4:22 pm
    All these illegal aliens who don't like the enforcement laws SB 1070 in Arizona should pack up and head for the Liberal Marxist state of California. They will find lax immigration laws under Liberal governor Jerry Brown and a heavy presence of Democrat in the Sacramento assembly. Even with the huge deficit Obama's people is currently giving out food stamps with no exemptions to illegal aliens. We already know these people who are here are robbing the states blind, as each must offer free health
  2. Smarter
    Report Abuse
    Smarter - September 18, 2012 7:37 pm
    Great news - thanks Judge Bolton!

    DGF - I hope you get the hotline phone number.
  3. DGF
    Report Abuse
    DGF - September 18, 2012 4:43 pm
    Everyone has to show "papers" when stopped. I don't get the problem. In the past couple weeks I have been called a racist twice, both by hispanic people. Both asked that I change the rules and when I would not I became a racist. Tired of the race card being played. Where is the hotline for me to call.
Add Comment
You must Login to comment.

Click here to get an account it's free and quick